Neurological Breach of Duty Expert Reports

Neurology breach of duty reports

Where the question is whether neurological care fell below a reasonable standard, our consultant neurologists give an independent, reasoned opinion on the care actually provided — addressed separately from causation.

Submit Case Enquiry

Overview

Independent Opinion on the Standard of Neurological Care

A breach of duty report answers one question: was the care provided within the range that a responsible body of neurological opinion would have supported at the time? It is a different question from causation, and the two are kept apart.

The expert works from the contemporaneous records rather than from hindsight. The standard applied is the standard at the date of the care, judged on what was known, available and reasonably practicable then.

Where the care is criticised, the report identifies the specific acts or omissions, what should have been done instead and by when. It also identifies whose standard is in issue — a consultant neurologist, a registrar on take, an emergency department clinician or a general practitioner — because the standard is that of the post, not of the individual holding it.

Where a responsible body of opinion would have acted as the clinician did, the report says so. An expert who cannot support a criticism is more use to the instructing solicitor early than late, and we would rather tell you at the screening stage than in a joint statement.

The expert’s duty is to the court and overrides any obligation to the party instructing or paying them (CPR Part 35). Reports are prepared on that basis whichever side instructs.

Areas of Analysis

Breach of Duty Issues We Assess

  • Delayed recognition of stroke, including decisions on thrombolysis and thrombectomy
  • Failure to investigate or act on red-flag neurological symptoms
  • Missed or delayed diagnosis of spinal cord compression
  • Management of seizures and status epilepticus
  • Prescribing, monitoring and withdrawal of neurological medication
  • Referral, follow-up, handover and the adequacy of clinical records
  • What the patient was told about the material risks of a treatment or procedure

Reporting Scope

What a Breach of Duty Report May Address

The standard reasonably expected of the clinician concerned at the date of the care

Whether the care fell outside the range a responsible body of neurological opinion would support

The specific acts or omissions criticised, and the reasons for each

The guidance, protocols and accepted practice applicable at the relevant time

The opinion relied on by the other side, and where the expert disagrees with it, on what basis

Matters outside the expert’s own field, identified rather than assumed

Assumptions, limitations and areas of genuine uncertainty, stated plainly

Routes to Instruction

Instruction Options

Claimant Instructions

A screening or full opinion on whether the neurological care is open to criticism, with the criticisms set out specifically enough to plead.

Defendant Instructions

An independent view of the care given, the practice accepted at the time and whether the criticisms made are supported by the records.

Joint Instructions

Where jointly instructed or appointed as a single joint expert, the neurologist answers the agreed questions on the material supplied by the parties.

Common Questions

Questions solicitors ask

What standard is the care judged against?

The standard of a responsible body of neurologists at the time of the care (Bolam), provided that view withstands logical analysis (Bolitho).

Is causation dealt with in the same report?

Breach and causation are addressed separately, by the same expert or by different experts. See our neurological causation reports.

How is hindsight avoided?

The expert judges the care on the information available at the time, not on the outcome that followed.

Get in Touch

Submit Case Enquiry on Breach of Duty

Complete the form below and our team will respond promptly to discuss the most appropriate expert for your case.